FeatureRonit Singh7 min read
A global chart should count every play the same. Billboard's still doesn't
Billboard just narrowed the gap on its US charts. Its global formula still counts a free stream at 22% of a paid one, and India's listeners pay the price.

Artwork: T-Series
In the week to 12 November, the most played song on YouTube anywhere in the world was a Punjabi ballad by a Sufi singer and poet from Punjab. Satinder Sartaaj's "Guzarish", released by T-Series on 16 September, climbed from No. 7 to No. 1 on YouTube's global Top Songs chart with a little over 42 million views. About three in every four of those plays came from India. It finished ahead of "Dai Dai", Shakira and Burna Boy's World Cup song, which has had a summer of World Cup stadiums and more than a billion views behind it.
That was no fluke week. On YouTube's weekly count of the most viewed music videos for the same seven days, seven of the top ten were Indian: Badshah and Shreya Ghoshal's "Mahiya", two new Hindi film songs with music by Himesh Reshammiya, Yo Yo Honey Singh's "Casa Tupka Anthemo", "Guzarish", and two devotional recordings, a Lakshmi Aarti in Diwali week and a Hanuman Chalisa, the kind of tracks many Indian homes play every morning.
Here is the argument. A chart that calls itself global has one job, which is to tell the world what the world is playing, and to do that it has to count every play the same. Billboard's global charts do not. On the formula Billboard published when it launched them, most of the plays above count for less than a quarter of a play.
What changed on 9 November
The fight that put this back on the table was American. In December 2025, Billboard cut the number of ad-supported streams it needs to equal one album sale on its US charts from 3,750 to 2,500, against 1,000 paid streams. YouTube said that was not enough and pulled its data from the US charts from the end of January 2026. Lyor Cohen, YouTube's global head of music, made YouTube's case on the company blog: the formula was outdated, and every stream should count equally, whatever the subscription behind it.
On 9 November, the two made up. From the Billboard 200 dated 16 January 2027, 1,500 ad-supported streams will equal one album unit, with paid streams still at 1,000, and the song charts, the Hot 100 included, are being reweighted along the same lines. YouTube updated the same blog post to say it is coming back. In eleven months, a free stream on the US charts has gone from a third of a paid stream to two thirds.
That is a big move, and it was made for America. This month's change is for the US charts.
The global formula, and who it shrinks
The Billboard Global 200 and the Global Excl. US chart launched in September 2020, built on data from more than 200 territories. The conversion published at launch: one track sale equals 200 premium streams, or 900 ad-supported ones. Put simply, a free stream counts at 2 ninths of a paid stream, about 22%. The weighting was set from a blended, worldwide figure for what each kind of stream earns.
Now put India through it. India is the third biggest streaming market in the world by volume, with 218.3 billion on-demand audio and video streams in the first half of 2026, behind only the US and Mexico, on Luminate's count. About 80% of those streams came from free, ad-supported services. Industry estimates put India's paid music subscribers somewhere between 14 and 20 million, against roughly 200 million people streaming free.
Do the sums. If 80 of every 100 Indian plays are free and each counts for 0.22, India's listening reaches the global chart at about 38% of its real size. Under the ratio Billboard has just given America, it would be about 73%. Count every play the same, and it is 100%.
Now look at where paid streams live. Luminate's 2025 year-end figures put 48.9% of the world's premium streams in four countries: the US, Mexico, Brazil and Germany. The US alone had 31%. A formula that discounts free plays is, in practice, a formula that turns up the volume on the countries where paying is the habit and turns it down on markets like India, where it is not.
The case for the discount, at its best
The other side has real arguments, and they deserve a fair hearing.
The first is commitment. Someone who pays every month has chosen music over everything else they could spend that money on. A chart, the argument goes, should weigh that choice.
The second is attention. Plenty of free plays are not really listening: autoplay, a video running in the background, a devotional track on a loop in a shop. A Hanuman Chalisa in that top ten is exactly the kind of play the discount was designed to catch.
The third is money, and it is the strongest. Billboard began as a trade paper. Its charts have always measured commerce, and a paid stream does bring in more than a free one. Billboard ties its ratios to an annual review of streaming revenue. On this view, the discount is not a judgement on free listeners. It is accounting.
And the system can still crown an Indian hit. In 2025, Faheem Abdullah's "Saiyaara" became the first Hindi-language song to reach the Global 200 top 10. So, the defenders say, the door is open.
Why it fails the moment it crosses a border
Take the money argument on its own terms, because that is where it breaks.
Spotify Premium costs Rs 139 a month in India. In the US it is $12.99. At any exchange rate of the past few years, the Indian plan costs well under a sixth of the American one. Yet on the global formula, a premium stream in Ludhiana and a premium stream in Los Angeles count exactly the same. If the chart were really measuring money, it would have to discount the Indian subscriber too. It does not, because it is not measuring money. It is measuring which kind of account you are logged into, and treating that as a stand-in for money, a stand-in that only holds inside one rich market.
A single blended ratio applied to 200 territories cannot track revenue in any of them. It just bakes in the price gap between the countries where people pay and the countries where they don't, and then calls the result a ranking of the world's music.
The attention argument cuts both ways. A Spotify Premium playlist murmuring behind a laptop in Berlin is as passive as a Lakshmi Aarti in a kitchen in Jaipur, and the formula counts the first in full. If the worry is background plays, police background plays, on every tier. The same goes for fraud. Billboard already runs audit rules against manufactured streams, and they apply to paid and free alike.
As for "Saiyaara": a song that needed one of the year's biggest Hindi films behind it to squeeze into the top 10 is not proof the door is open. It shows how high the step is. "Guzarish" is the more ordinary case, a hit with tens of millions of plays a week that a play-counting chart puts at No. 1 and a money-weighted one shrinks by most of its size.
Commitment is the weakest card of all. A student in Patna on a free account who plays "Mahiya" 40 times this week is not less of a fan than a subscriber in Ohio who plays it twice. They are less of a customer. That is a different thing, and a global chart has no reason to reward it.
Two charts, two worlds
None of this means the US charts must count every stream the same. A domestic chart inside one market, with one price list, can reasonably argue about how paid and free compare, and Billboard and YouTube have just settled that argument for America at 1.5 to 1. We have made a similar point about the American system before: the RIAA still certifies Spanish-language records on a smaller scale, and the line it draws says more about the industry than about the music.
A global chart is a different tool. Its whole promise is that a play in Lagos, Jakarta, São Paulo and Ludhiana is weighed on the same scale. The only unit that converts cleanly across 200 territories is the play itself. Three minutes of "Guzarish" is three minutes in any currency.
Right now, two of the most watched music charts on earth are showing two different worlds. YouTube's, which counts plays, had Punjabi, Hindi, Korean and Uzbek songs crowding its top ten last week. Billboard's, which counts plays as if they were money, has the world tilted towards four countries where people pay. From January, YouTube's data comes back into the American charts at a fairer rate. The global chart is where that fix was needed most, and it has not had it.
Up next
Sweet Mother is 50, and Africa's favourite song still can't be counted
Its sales run from 3 to 15 million copies, depending on who you ask. On YouTube, an unofficial 2007 upload outdraws the label's own nearly 300 to one.
Share this story



